Loading car advice...
Loading car advice...


SHOWDOWN
Fiat's retro charm vs. Polo's polished practicality—who'll take the crown in this small car showdown?
The Volkswagen Polo takes the crown in this small car showdown, excelling in practicality and comfort while still maintaining a stylish presence. We compared the Fiat 500 and Volkswagen Polo, focusing on styling, comfort and space, performance and driving capabilities, tech and features, alongside pricing. The Polo’s spacious interior and superior ride quality stand out against the Fiat 500’s retro charm and cheeky design, making it the better choice for everyday driving without sacrificing style.
| Styling | Comfort & Space | Performance | Tech & Infotainment | Overall | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fiat 500 | 9 | 6 | 7 | 6 | 28 |
| Volkswagen Polo | 7 | 9 | 8 | 8 | 32 |
Is it right for you?
The winner on paper might not be the winner for your life.
In the bustling world of small cars, the Fiat 500 and Volkswagen Polo stand out like two proud peacocks at a hen party. While each has its virtues, they're as different as chalk and cheese. This comparison aims to peel back the layers and help you decide which tiny titan deserves your hard-earned cash. We’ll be assessing styling, comfort and space, performance and driving capabilities, tech and features, alongside pricing—essentially everything you need to know to avoid any buyer's remorse! For a deeper dive into small cars, check out our article on best cars for commuting.


Fiat 500
9
Volkswagen Polo
7
The Fiat 500 exudes a retro charm reminiscent of a 1960s Italian film, with its compact shape, rounded edges, and colorful rooftop options that scream style over substance. In contrast, the Volkswagen Polo has a more polished, modern look—sporty lines and a subtle elegance that will still turn heads but might not set hearts racing like its whimsical rival. Its design is classic, refined, and unmistakably Volkswagen, but sometimes it can feel a tad too conservative next to the flamboyance of the Fiat.
If we’re talking sheer visual flair, the Fiat 500 clinches it with its playful, fashionable design, inviting you to hop in and feel youthful again, whereas the Polo plays it safe, winning on class but lacking pizzazz that makes car lovers swoon.

Fiat 500
6
Volkswagen Polo
9
Step inside the Fiat 500 and you’re transported to a colorful world filled with quirky touches, but the novelty soon fades against the dash of practicality in the Polo. The Polo’s interior steers away from cheeky gimmicks and instead boasts a high-quality finish with soft-touch materials and a generally mature ambiance, making it feel like a small luxury car.
When it comes to space, the Polo feels like a vast palace compared to the cramped citadel of the Fiat 500. The back seats in the Fiat are better suited for pets or under-twelves, while adults in the Polo will find ample legroom and headroom—even enjoying a decent tryst with comfort on longer journeys.


Fiat 500
7
Volkswagen Polo
8
The Fiat 500 comes with a lone 1.0-litre mild-hybrid engine that’s friendly on fuel but somewhat lacking in punch, barely scratching the surface when you need to merge onto a busy motorway. The Polo, especially in 1.0 TSI flavour, showcases a sprightlier character with acceleration that genuinely gets you moving without breaking into a sweat.
Check finance options
Monthly payments, no commitment
Which one suits you?
Get a personalised answer from Bobi


Fiat 500
6
Volkswagen Polo
8
Fiat's infotainment system can be a touch confusing, with menus that seem to have a mind of their own, whereas the Polo's 8.0-inch touchscreen, though peeking into the realm of being fiddly at times, generally gives a swift and easy user experience, bolstered by consistent smartphone connectivity across the board. Looking for more about infotainment systems?
Fiat 500
Overall
28
Volkswagen Polo
Overall
32
BOBI'S VERDICT
Let's talk dollars and pounds—starting prices for the Fiat 500 hover around £15,000 while the Polo begins its journey from £21,210. While price might suggest the Polo is the pick of the litter, if you prioritize style and city living, you might find the Fiat a worthy contender despite its slightly inflated pricing compared to some rivals. Check the detailed trims and listings here for Fiat and here for Polo.
So, which car deserves your quids? If you'd prefer chic style, a tight-knit urban feel, and a distinctive design, the Fiat 500 is the darling of the city. However, if practicality, driving comfort, and overall performance stroll hand-in-hand with your priorities, the Volkswagen Polo is the better pick, offering a well-rounded experience that will happily accommodate road trips, supermarket runs, and everything in between. While both these cars have their quirks, if your heart still thinks Fiat is fabulous—don't fret. Just ensure the size fits your lifestyle!
Fiat 500
Overall
28
Volkswagen Polo
Overall
32
Ultimately, if you want a car that offers room to stretch out (and heaven forbid you bring those pesky long-legged friends along), the Volkswagen Polo takes the trophy with its spacious cabin, while the Fiat 500 makes a valiant effort but leaves too much to be desired.
When it comes to ride comfort, the Polo is a true champ, gliding over imperfections with the grace of a prima ballerina. The Fiat 500 can feel a bit bouncy on the typical urban battlefield, rattling over potholes and inducing a squirm or two. If you're a city dweller, the Fiat’s nimbleness wins points, but the Polo excels on longer stretches.
As for driving tech, the Polo has the edge with modern features like automatic emergency braking and adaptable cruise control, leaving the Fiat wanting; it’s a fun romp around town but no luxe driving aids on board, making longer drives a slight stress. Check out a detailed comparison of the features in both cars.
In the race for driving pleasure and performance, the Polo takes top honors with its better engine options, superior comfort, and a suite of tech features, while the Fiat 500 is like that charming friend—great for a brief jaunt but not ideal for a long adventure.
The Polo also boasts a slightly more impressive array of features, with higher trims giving you built-in navigation and attractive ambient lighting—while the Fiat offers the essentials but loses out on the luxury front. Overall, it feels like the Polo has studied hard for its exams while the Fiat is busy working on its look.
As for boot space, the Polo truly shines at 351 liters, perfect for road trips or massive Aldi runs! The Fiat, on the other hand? A paltry 185 liters leaves much to be desired—a suitcase and a half is all it can muster! Check the boot space comparison for more insights.
In this battle of bells and whistles, the Volkswagen Polo emerges triumphant, flaunting superior tech, better usability, and a trunk that’ll happily swallow your luggage while the Fiat 500 leaves you longing for a little more.